Monday, February 23, 2009

Is There Anybody Out There?: What Other Golf Bloggers Are Talking About

This week I spent some time wandering through the blogoshere to find others committed to following the latest in golf problems and solutions. I would have to say that I did not feel to great about the sport after reading Chris Henry’s piece, “The Screws Tighten” at Eagle Par Birdie. His entry directed me to an article that shows starkly different data on green fee prices and number of rounds played on which I had previously reported, and paints a very gloomy picture. I am interested to find out what Mr. Henry thinks the industry will have to do in order to adapt to the slumping economy. Maybe I can get his opinion on the next piece, too. In Deeds & Weeds, a blog on Golf Digest’s website focused on Real Estate and Finance, Geoff Russell took a more narrow focus in detailing two cases in which country clubs are offering rounds to the public in hopes of increasing revenues. In “Ohio Club Allows Public Play: A Sign of the Times?” Mr. Russell may have found an opportunity for other struggling country clubs in America. The piece is very interesting and brings to my attention a new strategy for private clubs. I enjoyed both posts and left comments for the authors, which you can view below.

“The Screws Tighten”
Comment

I, too, am deeply troubled by the challenges the game of golf must face in 2009, so much so that I created a blog last month to explore the subject. This is a topic I want to find more about, and I appreciate your post and link to the article on Golf.com. It seems apparent now that the industry over invested in Tiger’s success and began opening courses at a rate the market could not support. I agree with you that the data looks gloomy, but if you get the chance, check out the January 2009 PGA PerformanceTrack data (I linked to it on my blog). The study compares 2008 data to 2007, and actually states that green fees went up last year. It sure is different from what the NGF is saying. I was rather surprised when I saw their data last week, it seemed too good to be true. They report that rounds played were down only 0.8% last year compared to 2007, and most of that looks attributable to poorer weather.

Anyways, what do you think course managers will have to do to keep people on the course? I came across another entry this week (also linked on my blog) that talks about a private course in Ohio that will allow public golfers to play on weekdays after noon and weekends after 2 p.m. You mentioned that golf courses are going to have to get creative, do you think this will work? I guess time will tell. I take comfort in knowing that at least this week, fans across America will actually watch the game, though. Thank God Tiger Woods is back.

“Ohio Club Allows Public Play: Sign of the Times?
Comment

Thank you for bringing this article to my attention. I have been exploring the game as it meets the challenges brought on by the lagging economy on my own blog since the beginning of the year. I believe this strategy may very well be one that other private clubs adopt in the coming quarters. From what I have read, there are a lot of club members that are seeking to sell their memberships, and even others losing their equity stakes because they can not make their monthly payments. Wildwood’s members must have been facing the same dilemma when they agreed to this policy. I am interested to find out if you agree with the move, do you think it will work? I can imagine some of the members are going to be really upset come April 1 when they have to share their beloved course with the public.

It is going to be an immensely challenging year for the sport, and I’m looking forward to reading more that you and Mr. Finch have to say about golf real estate and finance. As you have shown in this post, course mangers are going to have to be creative in order to stay alive. I do not believe, however, that the line between public and private golf courses should be so blurred. Wildwood’s managers have probably already tried other options, like lowering initial membership fees to attract new golfers or lowering annual fees to keep their current members. I hope, for their sake, that the strategy works. However, I think that as soon as the economy moves in the right directions, they should stop this policy and work on making their members appreciate again what it means to be a in a club. And, to be perfectly candid, I’ve never been in one.

9 comments:

  1. damn...not sure if that last comment saved or not.

    anyways, i'll try again...couldn't find your contact info, but really like your idea with this thing. any interest in exchanging links for each other's blogrolls?

    stop by tunagolf.wordpress.com or shoot me an email at spencer09600@gmail.com and let us know.

    thanks,

    spencer096

    ReplyDelete
  2. Welcome to the Blogsphere

    ReplyDelete
  3. Though I have never played golf myself, I am fully aware of the lucrative nature of the game of golf as I come from an area riddled with country clubs and private courses. It is no surprise that you would be interested in the basic statistics of the income (or lack there off this year) during a recession. What I am most impressed with is the fact that you not only did your "homework" by finding such statistics, but compared them to come up with a comprehensive conclusion on your own before even looking at another blogger's opinion. You came to the table well informed and prepared to ask relevant, in depth questions instead of merely surface level inquiries. The golf world has benefited from your use of numerical and comparative evidence which also bolsters your own argument as well. Your links also strategically added to your argument. If someone did not want to take your word for it, the evidence was there for their own eyes. You also addressed each blogger in the professional, considerate manner in which they deserved. This is something, as you know, I failed to do this week.

    Now I must move away from showering you with praises to give you ideas that you could add to your arsenal. The first point I wish you to look at is the consistency of style in your world choice. It will not only give your blog credibility, but will make it more engrossing to read whether you are looking for statistical data or not. For instance, instead of saying that you were "really upset" you could say that you were "greatly disheartened." It gives it a more professional tone, rhetorically speaking, and also matches the level of writing at which the rest of the blog resides. Secondly, the trend of talking about how the economy is effecting their industry, though relevant and important, is getting to be slightly redundant. I encourage you next time to think slightly more out of the box and come up with a new take on an intriguing issue. Though bloggers tend to write about the same issues since it is current event driven, the more interesting ones take a stance or propose an issue concerning said event that most people would not have thought of on their own. I feel with golf, being such a personality driven sport when it comes to the media, is ripe with possibilities.

    Wonderful job and good luck with future posts.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am greatly disheartened.

    I feel the nature of the 'Gen X' and 'Gen Y' beast is more of the cause of the golf industry's malaise than any current financial issues. These generations have money spending and social habits that are dramatically different than the 'Baby Boomers'. The dual income family has more equally proportioned the husband/wife free time issues and the statistics for parental time spent with their children are vastly different than their predecessors.

    To make it short and sweet - young adults have very little desire to belong to private country clubs. It is no longer a sign of a affluence to most of them. And they will not spend 5-6 hours to play any sport that takes them away from their desires to spend maximum face time with their children.

    Country clubs had declining memberships and non-private courses were deep discounting greens fees in 2005-2006.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Malcolm. You have a wonderful blog. Thank you very much.

    ReplyDelete
  6. spencer096-

    Thank you very much for the comment. I've added your blog to my linkroll. I really like what you have going on at Tuna Golf. Keep up the good work, I will be sure to follow.

    -Malcolm

    ReplyDelete
  7. Scot-

    Thanks for the note. I just added Mr Business Golfer and Business Golf Country Club to my linkroll. Reading your story, I am extremely impressed with the task you have been given and the work you have done for the game. I would like to join the Business Golf Country Club, but not sure if you will allow a college student. You can be sure to see a comment in the next week or two on some of your posts. Thanks again for reaching out to me.

    -Malcolm

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. One-Eyed Golfer-

    I appreciate such a well thought out and opinionated comment. The work on your blogs seems equally in line with your contribution. You bring up a really interesting point, my generation (and the one before me) really does not have the time or interest to play the game and join country clubs. This is a topic in which I am going to invest more time, and I hope you follow my next pots because I would like to hear more of what you think. Thanks again for the response.

    -Malcolm

    ReplyDelete

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.